Family money

Lending money to a sibling NZ: the $100,000 one brother had to chase for three years

By Blake Carter ·

One brother lent the other $250,000 in 2015. There was no written record of the deal.

$150,000 came back with interest. The last $100,000 didn't.

Getting it back took three years of asking, a District Court case and a High Court appeal.

Stuff covered the judgment. Here's the full story on Stuff.

If you've searched lending money to a sibling NZ before saying yes to a brother or sister, this case is worth a read.

The brother who lent won. But look at what it cost him to get there.

What everyone thought was agreed

Money had moved between these two brothers before.

A few years earlier the brother who later borrowed had given the other one $50,000. There had been other family loans back in 2003.

So when one of them was short in 2015, asking the other felt normal.

He was a businessman and lawyer with property interests around the country. He needed money to pay tax debts.

His brother lent him $250,000.

That's how a lot of family lending works. You've helped each other before. You trust each other.

The handshake

Nothing was written down. No repayment date. No terms on paper.

The brother who lent understood it was repayable after a year. Or earlier if he and his partner needed it to buy a house.

The brother who borrowed understood something different. He said he didn't have to pay until money came in from a property development in Wanaka.

Both versions sound reasonable. Neither was on paper.

The drift

The first $150,000 came back with interest. That part worked.

For a while the brother who lent was willing to wait. The judge said he was willing "although not necessarily happy".

In March 2016 he told his brother they hadn't found a house yet. He mentioned he had a tax bill due in April. He wanted a bit left to live on for the rest of the year.

Later in 2016 he noticed his brother had bought a new car. He also learned the family had been on overseas holidays.

He messaged asking for his $100,000. He pointed out that money didn't look like a problem any more.

By early 2017 he was asking for it as soon as possible.

His brother said he was waiting on a resource consent. Once that came through $4 million of section sales in Wanaka could settle.

This is the bit that happens in most family loans. Nobody is lying. Each brother is working off his own memory of a conversation from two years earlier.

The trigger

In early 2018 the lender's lawyers sent a formal demand. Ten days to pay.

It wasn't paid.

That's the moment a family loan stops feeling like family. Once lawyers are writing the letters, nobody is sorting it out over a beer any more.

He took his brother to the District Court for the $100,000 plus interest.

Lending money to a sibling NZ: what the law does

In New Zealand, if a family loan has no agreed repayment date, the lender can ask for it back whenever they like.

That's the rule this whole case turned on.

What the court decided

The District Court judge found the borrowing brother had no reasonably arguable defence. He was ordered to repay the $100,000 plus interest.

He appealed to the High Court.

His argument was that the real deal was to pay once the Wanaka subdivision was done.

The High Court didn't accept it.

The judge said if that had really been the deal, he would have mentioned it in the emails between them much earlier than he did.

She said the informal way the loans were made fitted with there being no firm agreement on repayment at all.

No firm date meant the money was due when his brother asked for it.

The judge agreed with the District Court. He lost, and he has to pay it back.

The one page that would have saved three years

This one went the lender's way. That's the good news.

The bad news is how long it took. Three years of messages. A lawyer's letter. Two courts.

Every one of those steps was about a single question. When was the money due?

A Friends & Family Loan Agreement answers that on the day the money moves.

It records the amount. It records the repayment date, or the event that triggers repayment.

It records whether there's interest. It records what happens if a payment is late.

If the deal really was "pay me back when Wanaka sells", that's one line on the page.

If the deal was "a year, or sooner if we buy a house", that's one line too.

Either way both brothers sign it. The argument about what was said in 2015 never starts.

It protects the brother who borrows too. A written date means nobody can call the loan in early because they've spotted a new car in the driveway.

It also means the lender doesn't have to send awkward messages for three years. The date is on the page. Both people already know it.

Family loans rarely go wrong because someone sets out to dodge a debt. They go wrong because two people remember the same handshake differently.

We covered a dad and daughter who fell out over $5,000 for the same reason. That one went the other way for the parent who paid.

Same problem. Different family. No piece of paper in either case.

Source: 'Where's my dough, bro?': Brothers head to court over unpaid $100,000 loan, Stuff, 23 November 2018.

Common questions

Can I ask for a family loan back if we never agreed a date?
In this case the High Court said a loan with no firm repayment date was repayable when the lender asked for it.
Does it matter that the loan was between brothers?
Here the court treated it as a loan because $150,000 had already been repaid with interest. The fight was only about when the rest was due.
What does a family loan agreement record?
The amount, the repayment date or the event that triggers repayment, any interest, and what happens if a payment is late.

Friends & Family Loan Agreement

Get it in writing before you transfer.

Build it, share it and co-sign it online. NZ$49 one-time, unlimited documents.

This is a summary of a case reported by Stuff, not legal advice. For your own situation, talk to a New Zealand-qualified lawyer.

More family money